Here are the pros and cons of achievement driven education:
Pros
1. Motivation and goal setting
Clear direction: Students in an achievement driven education system are often given clear goals and standards to meet. For example, in a curriculum with standardized tests, students know exactly what they need to achieve in terms of knowledge and skills. This clarity helps them focus their efforts and can be motivating as they work towards specific, measurable targets.
Encourages hard work: The emphasis on achievement can instill a strong work ethic in students. They learn to strive for excellence, put in the necessary time and effort to succeed, and develop perseverance. This can be beneficial in their future academic and professional pursuits.
2. Accountability and quality assurance
Teacher and school performance: Achievement driven education holds educators and educational institutions accountable for student outcomes. Schools are motivated to maintain high quality teaching and learning environments to ensure that students achieve good results. This can lead to continuous improvement in teaching methods, curriculum design, and school resources.
Standardization and fairness: Standardized assessments, which are often a part of achievement driven education, aim to provide a fair and objective measure of student learning across different schools and regions. This allows for comparisons and helps to identify areas where students may need additional support or where the education system as a whole needs to be improved.
3. Preparation for the future
College and career readiness: Achieving good grades and meeting academic requirements in an achievement driven system can better prepare students for higher education and the workforce. For example, a high school student who has excelled in a rigorous, achievement focused curriculum is more likely to be competitive in the college admissions process and may have developed the skills necessary for success in a particular career.
Cons
1. Narrow focus on grades and scores
Stress and burnout: The heavy emphasis on achieving high grades and test scores can put excessive stress on students. They may feel pressured to constantly perform at a high level, leading to burnout, anxiety, and a negative attitude towards learning. For example, students may sacrifice their hobbies, sleep, and social lives to study for exams, which can have a negative impact on their overall well being.
Limited learning scope: There is a risk that students will focus solely on what is required to get good grades rather than on a broader understanding of the subject matter. They may engage in rote learning to pass tests instead of developing critical thinking, creativity, and a love for learning. This can limit their long term intellectual growth and ability to apply knowledge in real world situations.
2. Inequality and unfairness
Disadvantaged students: Achievement driven education can exacerbate existing inequalities. Students from low income families, those with learning disabilities, or those in under resourced schools may face greater challenges in meeting the same achievement standards as their more privileged peers. For example, they may not have access to high quality tutoring, advanced courses, or a stable home environment conducive to studying, which can put them at a disadvantage in the pursuit of academic achievements.
Teaching to the test: In some cases, teachers may feel compelled to "teach to the test" in order to boost their students' scores. This can lead to a narrow and formulaic curriculum that does not fully explore the richness of the subject matter. It also may not meet the diverse learning needs of all students.
3. Lack of emphasis on holistic development
Neglect of non academic skills: An overemphasis on academic achievement may mean that non academic skills such as emotional intelligence, social skills, and physical health are neglected. These skills are also crucial for a well rounded and successful life. For example, students may not have enough time or opportunities to develop teamwork, communication, or self management skills in an achievement driven educational environment that is primarily focused on academic results.
|
|
|手机版|标签|新闻移动网xml|新闻移动网txt|全球新闻资讯汇聚于 - 新闻移动网
( 粤ICP备2024355322号-1|
粤公网安备44090202001230号 )
